Review Tonight! "Twin Peaks" S02E02 "Coma"

Did you manage to stay awake during this episode? Grade it now, please.

  • 10

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 9

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 8

    Votes: 2 50.0%
  • 7

    Votes: 1 25.0%
  • 6

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 5

    Votes: 1 25.0%
  • 4

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 3

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 2

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 1

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    4

Mad-Pac

Member: Rank 5
Aired Thursday 9:00 PM Oct 06, 1990 on ABC

Agent Cooper receives unwanted help and unwelcome news, and Audrey gets into deeper trouble.


CAST

Kyle MacLachlan ... Special Agent Dale Cooper
Michael Ontkean ... Sheriff Harry Truman Burbank
Mädchen Amick ... Shelly Johnson
Dana Ashbrook ... Bobby Briggs
Richard Beymer ... Benjamin Horne
Lara Flynn Boyle ... Donna Hayward
Sherilyn Fenn ... Audrey Horne
Warren Frost ... Dr. Will Hayward
Peggy Lipton ... Norma Jennings
James Marshall ... James Hurley
Everett McGill ... Big Ed Hurley
Jack Nance ... Pete Martell
Kimmy Robertson ... Lucy Moran
Ray Wise ... Leland Palmer
Joan Chen ... Jocelyn Packard
Eric DaRe ... Leo Johnson
Harry Goaz ... Deputy Andy Brennan
Sheryl Lee ... Maddy Ferguson
Chris Mulkey ... Hank Jennings
Miguel Ferrer ... FBI Agent Albert Rosenfield
David Patrick Kelly ... Jerry Horne
Don S. Davis ... Major General George Hammond
Victoria Catlin ... Blackie O'Reilly
Don Amendolia ... Emory Battis
Frances Bay ... Mrs. Tremond
Grace Zabriskie ... Sarah Palmer
Catherine E. Coulson ... The Log Lady
Phoebe Augustine ... Ronette Pulaski
Austin Jack Lynch ... Little Boy
Jill Pierce ... Ice-Bucket Girl
Mak Takano ... Asian Man
Don Mantooth ... Sleep Subject



WRITING CREDITS

Mark Frost ... (created by) &
David Lynch ... (created by)

Harley Peyton ... (written by)


DIRECTED BY

David Lynch
 

Bob Peters 61

Member: Rank 2
First, looks like the long intro was only for series- and season-premiers so we're back to just a tease of that saw-sharpener. :emoji_disappointed:

Looks like Andy's role as comedy relief is officially cemented. First when he was hanging up the sketch flier and appeared to have lost a fight with a roll of Scotch tape. Then the parallel between his pacing outside the door and the buzzing bug that was bugging Lucy.

At least we know why he reacted the way he did to her pregnancy news. But did the sperm bank tell him specifically that he was sterile or just that he had a low sperm count? The latter can get him rejected as a sperm donor for significantly reducing the probability of conception while not entirely making it impossible. Like the scene in the old Mary Tyler Moore Show where Ted questioned his wife's happy news on that basis and she answered that apparently one of the little boogers got the job done.

As for Hank, we now know that Harry's little vigilante group had proved a gateway to crime for at least one of his better guys. Gee, who could have seen that coming? :emoji_rolling_eyes: Still doubtful that Bobby would rat him out for saving him from the receiving end of Leo's impression of Lizzie Bordon.

Bobby and Shelly are playing a dangerous game. Betting that Leo's joined the plant kingdom should he come out of that coma. If not, I wouldn't wanna be either of them.

Now we know why the father-son moment had such a "goodbye" vibe to it. Maj. Biggs just deliberately divulged classified information to a federal agent, revealing that he was working with SETI type of alien transmissions which as of Cooper's shooting turned out to be from the planet Betazed, where the holder of the Sacred Chalice of Rixx is now beaming her most valued assistant in to feed cryptic clues to the good G-man.:emoji_vulcan:

Bob the boogeyman is quite a scary one. What the actor who played Leo may have lacked in intimidation value this guy made up for. I doubt Meat Loaf could have played a similar character that scary. But maybe he's really not. Coop's latest revelation did label him as an owl who's not what he seems.

Typical of the foolishness of youth, Audrey has tipped her hand to the wrong guy just to choke out of him information that had already been revealed to her had she been paying more attention. You'd think being the owner's daughter would give her a little better class of protection than that, though. So what shall become of her situation?

Nice suspense-builder to bring us back to the edges of our seats. 8 forgotten letters under the bed.
 
Last edited:

Brimfin

Member: Rank 3
Okay, Audrey, repeat after me, “I’m at One-Eyed Jacks. I’m at One-Eyed Jacks.” That’s all you had to say and then Cooper would have descended on the place with his entourage to rescue you – foreign territory, be damned. But no, you waste time complimenting how he looked in his tuxedo and saying, “I’m coming home now” while you’re still standing there inside the building in your black teddy. Audrey, you’re an idiot!

Meanwhile, the real mystery is not “Who killed Laura Palmer?” but “Who knocked up Lucy Moran?” Andy’s behavior of earlier was explained since he has been diagnosed as sterile so the baby cannot be his. (Unless it turns out they mixed up his diagnosis or something, but that could never happen here, right?) She provides no help once again as she moves to whisper something to him, but only rips some tape off his head instead. Until next week…

Albert actually shows a sense of humor which doesn't involve insulting other people by substituting the contents of Jacques’ stomach with that of a shark in the movie JAWS and the whale in PINOCCHIO. He even then ties it in to Cooper’s ramblings about “the happy generation” or whatever the heck it was he was going on about.

The log lady actually delivered a message from her log to Major Briggs, telling him to “Deliver the message.” He then goes to Cooper and delivers a message that was heard in outer space among space gibberish and garbage, mainly that “The Owls Are Not What They Seem” (prediction #2 from the friendly giant last week.) He knew it had to go to Cooper because the aliens repeated “Cooper” over and over again, and Cooper is not a common name. Well, actually it is… Just another typical week in Twin Peaks.

And Josie….well, her name is still in the credits but we don’t see hide or hair of her. Meanwhile, Catherine’s name is out of the credits and ….well, we don’t see her either.

Oh, and since the episode is entitled “Coma”, we have Ronnette Pulaski (doesn’t that name remind you of Roman Polanski? That can’t be a coincidence. He was involved in the drugging of a young girl, too.) coming out of her coma? Too weak to talk yet, she does react in fear to a sketch of Bob. Speaking of “Bob”, Maddy sees a vision of him late in the episode. As Albert points out, no one can claim that they’ve actually seen this guy yet.

And Leo Johnson is supposedly in a coma, and Shelly will have to take him home if she wants to collect his pension (or rather it’s Bobby who is trying to convince her to do that.) But we saw his eyes open briefly and don’t we all just know that if she takes him home he’ll not only wake up from his coma, he’ll end up tying up either Shelly or Bobby and making them watch while he tortures the other one.

That’s the highlights from this week, except for Donna checking out the “Meals on Wheels” clue and the mysterious little boy who does magic and preparing to meet with the neighbor with the sinister name “Mr. Smith.” Okay, I guess it’s not really sinister, but certainly not as common as Cooper, right? Never Mind.

Since I fell asleep halfway through it, and had to watch the second half later, I’ll give this 5 little boys cupped hands holding creamed corn. Yuk.

Best line of the week:

Albert: “Your former partner flew the coop, Coop.”
 

Brimfin

Member: Rank 3
Mad-Pac said:
Roddy McDowall ... Galen (segment 'Planet of the Apes')
That was from episode 8. Clever past reference to Planet of the Apes. (And just in time, too, as the “Invitation to Love” segments appear to have been eliminated since then).

On to last week:

Mad-Pac said:
Yes, it was one gag credit reference. This is the time a character or actor from one of our previous shows is referenced. Can you remember where we did see Richard Kiel?
Ah, yes, Richard Kiel played the Giant Indian in “Bad Medicine” and the Spanish Moss Monster in “The Spanish Moss Murders,” both in KOLCHAK: THE NIGHT STALKER.

The other gag credit was
Mad-Pac said:
Don S. Davis ... Major General George Hammond
That was his character in STARGATE SG-1. I see you left it in this week as well, patiently waiting for someone to finally notice.

But there was one gag credit you probably weren’t aware of – the title. You have “May the Giant Man Be With You” while the actual title was simply “May the Giant Be With You.”

And finally, this week:

Mad-Pac said:
Don Mantooth ... Sleep Subject
How appropriate. Our guest star from “The Spanish Moss Murders” episode of KOLCHAK who was in a coma of sorts, but never woke up. Leo Johnson, please take the hint.
 

Mad-Pac

Member: Rank 5
Well, well. The Twin Peaks slump is back and it looks like it's going to stay for a good part of the season. I have the feeling writers will only get things going when they know there aren't many episodes left. I still think the overall achievement of Twin Peaks is significant, but to face it bit by bit, week by week is not a very appealing prospect at the moment. However, after I skip some parts and watch the highlights (after having watched the full version), I realize there are lots of interesting elements scattered all over the place. And lots of crazy as well. So, I'm conflicted.

Basically, the investigation continues and will continue. So, for instance, Ronette Pulaski has woken up from her coma. (Yay!) But she can't speak yet. (Darn it!) Anyway, Agent Rosencrantz (or something), a representative of one of the Happy Generations, gives Agent Cooper the lowdown. But even focusing on important investigative elements, that doesn't stop Cooper from having interest in... stuff, like Buddhist tradition in the land of snow. Long story short, Cooper plans to show Ronette pictures of imaginary people he saw in his dream to see if that triggers her memory. And a strange man whose outfit and demeanor screams (FBI AGENT!) observes Cooper discreetly, as if this town received thousands of unknown visitors every day and a guy like that could disappear among all other patrons.I think that's Cooper's missing FBI partner he talks about later.

Donna takes Laura's place in the "Meals on Wheels" program. She serves an old lady, who is also accompanied by her grandson a creepy weird kid who's studying magic, wears a tux, has an eerily detached attitude and speaks in riddles. Or, you know, just a regular kid, of course.

Ben and Jerry concoct other schemes and their dilemma is which ledger to burn, the real or the fake one. But the reality is, one of them has to go, so why not burn both? Sure, why not. And they are also trying to deal with the fact Catherine apparently died (so how can take advantage from that?), but hasn't signed the insurance policy that would've made their crooked plans work.

We have an unexpected interaction between The Log Lady and "General Hammond". Sorry, but Don. S. Davies will always be General Hammond to me. She gives him a message from the Log. The military man claims he and the log haven't properly been introduced, but that was very stupid of him because, of course, she never introduces the log. It's just a log and even she seems to know that. Or not... She gives him a message he's supposed to pass to Cooper. Why she doesn't go to Cooper directly, I have no idea. But then I'm here just fo the ride.

Lucy is having trouble with a noisy mosquito (I think) and for a moment I think she']s playing with a drone, flying it all over the office. This is one more of those examples of how modern life intrudes in a story that takes place decades ago.

Ok, so we finally learn why Andy reacted the way he did: the's sterile, so how could he be the baby's father? Things don't look good for Lucy, but I hope the writers manage to find an explanation that will make her the good girl she seems to be and doesn't make Andy look like a chump. Personally i find Lucy so awfully cute that I would have a very hard time forgiving her, no matter what she did.

Hank is being creepy and he tries to intimidate Cooper and Truman with his creepiness. And in their office, even though Lucy specifically asked him to wait outside. But that doesn't work and Cooper isn't even fazed.

Ben calls the sheriff to inform him Audrey is missing. Like any good father, he waited two days to reveal that and he didn't seem particularly worried. Cooper gets devastated by the news, and in case you weren't sure of that he says that on one of those insta-recordings/message tapes that are magically transmitted to Diane in real time, other wise what would be the point of telling things that are happening at that very moment, but soon could be meaningless? And are certainly meaningless to a secretary. Oh, well, once again, I don't know.

Meanwhile Leland isn't singing anymore; instead, he uses his voice now to make inconvenient calls to clients overseas telling them about the town pecadillos Ben wish would remain hidden. Leland identifies the "imaginary" assailant from the drawing Cooper ordered passed around to the public and leland says that was a man that used to freak him out when he was a kid. So, if that's true... The man must be 80 now? Ben's reaction: "Jerry, please kill Leland". Sounds like a joke, but with Ben horne, we can never tell.

Shelly faces the reality that Leo will most likely be paralyzed, but now he's in a coma. Bobby doesn't seem to have any problem with that and is just thinking of spending Leo's money with Shelly. Basically, a win-win situation.

Audrey keeps on investigating and getting deep in the underworld of prostitution. How she has managed to do that and remain "pure" so far is something that eludes me.

Ha! I know Briggs was General Hammond in disguise. He visits Cooper to deliver the message and reveals information he could only have obtained if he worked in the Stargate project. Basically, Cooper is being contacted by aliens... Waitaminnit! Aliens? WTF? But the scene is rather quick and it's not a big deal after all, not in the life of Agent Mulder, I mean, Cooper.

The trio of the oldest "kids" you can find decide to have a singing rehearsal because... Oh, why do things need a reason to happen? The music is nice and the execution very cutesy. But Donna feels so suffocated by the growing sexual tension that arises among James, (hey, kids, get a room you three.) "Lauraddie" and herself that she has a mini tantrum. But her tantrum is not as big as Maddie's, who has a disturbing vision of that assailant that has been assailing everybody's dreams and hallucinations. At the same time, Ronette gets agitated, and Cooper sees the giant man again with an ornithological riddle.

And Audrey calls Cooper! She says "i saw you in a tuxedo and looked like a movie star", but initially I heard, "I'm sorry I haven']t texted you..." But of course, not because, duh, text messages didn't exist back then. he call is interrupted. Oh, my God, what's gonna happen? Etc, etc. Next week we'll know more.

My initial reaction was negative. Now, giving the episode a second chance, I found many interesting passages forming a bizarre puzzle. I hope I manage to appreciate that in the first viewing next time.

"Coma" almost put me in one, but it has redeeming qualities.
Episode 2 deserves 7 owls that are exactly what they seem.

 

Bob Peters 61

Member: Rank 2
Lucy is having trouble with a noisy mosquito (I think) and for a moment I think she']s playing with a drone, flying it all over the office. This is one more of those examples of how modern life intrudes in a story that takes place decades ago.
I figured it must be either a horsefly or a wasp. Not nearly high pitched enough to be a mosquito. Too loud to be an ordinary housefly unless it was amplified for comic effect, which is a definite possibility.
 

Brimfin

Member: Rank 3
Mad-Pac said:
Personally I find Lucy so awfully cute that I would have a very hard time forgiving her, no matter what she did.
Did you mean to say, "Personally I find Lucy so awfully cute that I would have a very hard time NOT forgiving her, no matter what she did." Myself, if I find somebody "awfully cute" I'm usually willing to forgive more easily.

I am reminded of this dialogue I wrote for a BRIMSTONE story. The character of Maggie is awfully cute (though scads smarter than Lucy.)

Maggie punches in the correct code after the alarm starts beeping. The beeping stops at once)
Tony: (stunned) How did you do that?
Maggie: (casually) Easy. When Weaver punched in his code earlier, I peeked!
Tony: You peeked? I'd have thought you'd be the last person on this planet to do a thing like that!
Maggie: (casually) How do you think I get away with it?
 
Last edited:

Mad-Pac

Member: Rank 5
That was from episode 8. Clever past reference to Planet of the Apes. (And just in time, too, as the “Invitation to Love” segments appear to have been eliminated since then).
Twin Peaks is a difficult show to play with the cast names with, because it's always the same people, with few exceptions.

Ah, yes, Richard Kiel played the Giant Indian in “Bad Medicine” and the Spanish Moss Monster in “The Spanish Moss Murders,” both in KOLCHAK: THE NIGHT STALKER.
Yep, both giants.

That was his character in STARGATE SG-1. I see you left it in this week as well, patiently waiting for someone to finally notice.

But there was one gag credit you probably weren’t aware of – the title. You have “May the Giant Man Be With You” while the actual title was simply “May the Giant Be With You.”
That's perhaps the most iconic character any Twin Peaks actor has played outside Twin Peaks.

Well, that's the title I found in tv.com.

How appropriate. Our guest star from “The Spanish Moss Murders” episode of KOLCHAK who was in a coma of sorts, but never woke up. Leo Johnson, please take the hint.
Yep, the whole coma theme sounds familiar.
 

Mad-Pac

Member: Rank 5
Mad-Pac said:
Personally I find Lucy so awfully cute that I would have a very hard time forgiving her, no matter what she did.

Did you mean to say, "Personally I find Lucy so awfully cute that I would have a very hard time NOT forgiving her, no matter what she did." Myself, if I find somebody "awfully cute" I'm usually willing to forgive more easily.
Ha! That's what I get by writing stuff at superspeed. What a Freudian slip! I guess I WOULDN'T forgive her after all. Still, she's adorable.

I am reminded of this dialogue I wrote for a BRIMSTONE story. The character of Maggie is awfully cute (though scads smarter than Lucy.)

Maggie punches in the correct code after the alarm starts beeping. The beeping stops at once)
Tony: (stunned) How did you do that?
Maggie: (casually) Easy. When Weaver punched in his code earlier, I peeked!
Tony: You peeked? I'd have thought you'd be the last person on this planet to do a thing like that!
Maggie: (casually) How do you think I get away with it?
Clever one!
 

Cloister56

Member: Rank 3
Right 1 donut down and it's episode 2.

We get some foreshadowing with the mentioning of Cooper's former partner. I assume that he suffered a breakdown after the previous murder to tie all this together. It would be interesting new element to introduce.

I was a bit confused at the Horne discussion. i thought the mill had burnt down as a shot last week showed burned out wrecks. But they consider using the false ledger to raise the price of the mill once they buy it from Josie, perhaps only part of the mill went up.
I like Lelands happy face when he nods that he was the one who told the Icelanders about the fire like he'd done something great.

We have an unexpected interaction between The Log Lady and "General Hammond".
I knew had a seen him somewhere in that kind of role, the other place was in the X-Files as I think he was Scully's dad. I'm glad Norma calls Log Lady out for her spitting out gum last week, that still was disgusting.
The report of his SETI giving a few coherent words is interesting. I'm not sure if it means aliens are communicating with Cooper. I am hoping it is more another force hijacking it. It does mean Coopers visions are able to affect the wider world which is interesting.

So what happened to the one armed shoe salesman. Did he ever meet with Truman? Unless I missed it, it didn't happen last week and this episode is the next day at least.

I am assuming that Lucy will still be pregnant from Andy. I wouldn't put it past Andy to have misunderstood the results also Lucy's actions fit more with someone annoyed at being presumed to have cheated when she hasn't.

As for Hank, we now know that Harry's little vigilante group had proved a gateway to crime for at least one of his better guys. Gee, who could have seen that coming? :emoji_rolling_eyes:
I am glad that happened. It smacked a little of good old boys going above the law for me, I liked the individual members but to see that their actions do have bad consequences made it more interesting. Often going above the law in TV or Movies is rewarded as being the right course of action.

Leo is now in a coma. At first I thought they had done a decent job, putting a fake tube at his mouth. But he appears to be on a hospital trolley not a bed. He is going to get pressure sores really quickly and unless that was a huge trolley he is about half way down it as well.
Bobby's plan to get Leo home seems a little far fetched. Is she going to get a ventilator and a full time nurse to look after him. That would eat through that $5000 in about 1 day.

Audrey is looking very nice still in her little dress. Does one Eyed Jacks run 24 hours a day? When do the girls get to go home.
Audrey does a nice job interrogating her former boss confirming Ben does own One-Eyes.
Audrey must have been missing for a while. She was at One-Eye when Cooper was shot, so day 1 would be episode 1, this is at least day 2. Considering a girl her age was murdered and another assaulted you would think at least her mother would have reported her absent day 1 and the whole town would be looking for her.

Okay, Audrey, repeat after me, “I’m at One-Eyed Jacks. I’m at One-Eyed Jacks.” That’s all you had to say and then Cooper would have descended on the place with his entourage to rescue you – foreign territory, be damned. But no, you waste time complimenting how he looked in his tuxedo and saying, “I’m coming home now” while you’re still standing there inside the building in your black teddy. Audrey, you’re an idiot!
Yeah, what was she thinking? Get that information out first then dish out the compliments.

Then we get James, Donna and Madeline singing away. Why? James isn't very good at lip syncing.
The sideways looks from Madeline seem to suggest there is sexual tension building there, I did wonder whether that might be the case given his history with Laura.
Donna's reaction is understandable, she can see what is happening right in front of her.
Overall that moment was brilliantly played by the 3 of them so it made the scene worth it.

Bob the boogeyman is quite a scary one. What the actor who played Leo may have lacked in intimidation value this guy made up for.
Yes I agree 100%, the scene where he slowly moves towards the camera and then climbs towards it/Madeline was chilling.

Although less happened in this episode I really quite enjoyed it for a few key scenes.

8 words Audrey "At One Eyed Jacks, Help, Liked Your Tuxedo" out of 10
 
Top